That's rather speedy, and no cheating. Clean grid, if not super-open. Looked like a Friday, and solved even easier.
More On Winning
It was round 3 of Friday Night Magic, and I was playing against my friend Craig. I had just lost to rival George. George is not very good at Magic, and I really hate it when I lose to him. But tonight, he just had a sick deck with a bomb rare, and I couldn't deal. The turn before I was going to die in the deciding game, I drew the one card that could save me, Prodigious Growth. I knew he had at least 2 Naturalizes in his deck to deal with 2 Luminous Bonds and a Heiromancer's Cage I had failed to draw that game. If he had the Naturalize, I lost. Otherwise, I won. I said "Show me Naturalize and I'll concede." He declined, so I cast the Growth and attacked. He cast Naturalize, and I flipped out, though I managed to stifle my language.
This is called a slow-roll, and it's very uncool. I maybe overreacted a little, but at least Craig agreed that it was, in fact, a slow-roll. And this story is actual supposed to be about Craig. I beat him game 1 rather soundly. While sideboarding for game 2, I asked him if he intended to play or draw. Strictly speaking, I'm not supposed to ask so early. His answer could theoretically alter my sideboard plans. That was clearly not my intent, but he seemed annoyed that I'd asked. While shuffling, I asked again. I do this because many players, myself included, sometimes forget to specify, and that can lead to miscommunication. He got really annoyed at this, like I was taunting him or something, and then went on to say he didn't enjoy playing me, because I never return his wish of "good luck." I explained I don't wish him bad luck, but to wish him good luck would be a lie. I was surprised at his affront, though. Many years ago, there was heated discussion about whether wishing someone good luck should be automatic. Some think so, some don't. I remember sitting down across from Mike Flores in the first round of a PTQ back in those old days, and he extended the hand before we even started, and said, "Lets have some fun today, Tim." Not luck, fun. I say that to my first round opponent at any major event now. I prefer the pre-game handshake because the post-game one can feel disingenuous, and even now there is debate on whether it's ok for the winner to offer a "gg" online or the handshake in real life What if the loser doesn't feel that way? Craig feels that there's something to be said for good will. In my mind, lying to my opponent or myself cannot possibly be good will. If someone is offended that I don't shake their hand after I lost to mana screw twice in a row, understand that "gg" stands for "Good Games."
I'm pretty sure Jon Finkel has never wished an opponent good luck. Here's a great story about Jon. Several years ago, Wizards got contacted by the Make a Wish Foundation. One of their sick kids wanted to meet some Magic pros, so WotC flew the kid down to Nationals or something, and he got to play some one-on-one Magic with Jon Finkel and Bob Maher. When Maher played the kid, he played nice, giving the kid advice. Then the kid played Jon and Jon systematically crushed him with no mercy. Bob was saying to Jon, "that was kinda mean." Jon said, "The kid wanted to play against the best. He wasn't there to beat us, he wanted to see the best players play their best." There is good will, and there is competition.
I view Craig as a friend. He may not like me as an opponent, but I hope he doesn't think less of me as a person because I don't wish him good luck. Many people are dear friends until they sit down across from me in a sanctioned tournament. Then they are a competitor. To treat them any differently than I would treat a professional is an insult to them and the game. I can understand, at FNM, it's not exactly the PT and we're not playing for many dollars, but Craig is serious enough, and I would hope he understands that it's because I respect him that I play hard against him.
Good night, and fair luck.